Restaurants

Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop

4.9 111 reviews 11:00 AM - 04:00 PM 505 Burro Ave Ste 112, Cloudcroft, NM 88317, United States

Discover this place

Located in the charming town of Cloudcroft, New Mexico, Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. The sandwich shop exudes a nostalgic vibe, reminiscent of the 70s and 80s, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Many customers rave about the fresh ingredients and delightful flavors found in the menu offerings.

Among the highlights, Amy McCorkle lauds their clam chowder as the best she's ever had, while others like Matt Wright recommend the toasted sandwiches, specifically highlighting the soft, flaky bread and the tasty “Leo’s Way” toppings of shrettuce, tomato, and oil & vine. From hearty Italian subs to a delectable TBA (turkey, bacon, avocado), there’s something for every palate.

Ashley Faye Holder and A K both note the exceptional customer service, with owner John taking the time to engage with guests, ensuring their satisfaction. Furthermore, A K appreciated the shop’s attention to dietary restrictions, making gluten-free options available without cross-contamination. The inviting ambiance and friendly, family-run atmosphere make every meal at Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop feel special. This hidden gem is definitely worth a visit for anyone in the area!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop before visiting.

Reviews for Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop

4.9

111 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 111 reviews

Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop consistently receives praise for its fresh, flavorful sandwiches and welcoming atmosphere. Customers highlight the quality of ingredients, with particular appreciation for toasted breads and unique dressings. The shop’s knowledgeable and attentive staff enhance the dining experience, demonstrating care especially towards dietary needs such as gluten-free options. The nostalgic, cozy ambiance adds to its charm, making it a favored stop for both locals and visitors. Family-run and community-oriented, the establishment is lauded for friendly service and a relaxing environment, often described as a perfect complement to local activities. Overall, Cloudcroft Sandwich Shop is widely regarded as a delightful spot that combines great food, thoughtful service, and inviting surroundings.

Amy McCorkle

Jul 10, 2025

Best clam chowder I’ve had IN MY LIFE. Everything was great, the lady at the front was such a nice lady. Place is beautiful and it brings back 70-80s vibes Masterpiece of a place I can’t express how much I love it , They would’ve allowed dogs if the state allowed it

Matt Wright

May 22, 2025

Delicious, fresh sandwiches. Def recommend getting them toasted and Leo’s Way (shrettuce, tomato, and oil & vin). The bread was also a particular standout: soft & flaky with a good crust from the toast. This was just what we were looking for while taking a break from Ski Cloudcroft.

Ashley Faye Holder

May 11, 2025

Our 1st stop in, won't be our last! I got the Italian & my husband got the TBA (turk, bac, avo). I got their garden herb dressing on my sub & it was fantastic! He ended up putting some on his as well it was so good. The owner, John, made it a point to ask how our meal was. Highly recommended

A K

May 01, 2025

This extra cute little sandwich shop totally delivered on a safe, delish gluten-free sub even though they are not a dedicated gluten-free place. I had the veggie sub Leo’s Way with some additions. The owner was super knowledgeable about celiac and cross-contamination. They used fresh veggie ingredients “from the back”. The sub was absolutely AMAZING!!! I would highly recommend this gem to anyone. I was so hungry that I forgot to take a Photo. Thank you!!!

natto _

Apr 27, 2025

Beautiful surroundings outside winds calm nice weather, the food is so yummy i love it ate it up so fast and enjoyed every second. Customer service is fantastic very kind people and its family ran i believe! Overall Wonderful Experience!!!! FIVE STARS cant wait to come again

Jay Porterfield

Apr 26, 2025

Great people and super accommodating. The food is excellent! We put them tp the task with our 20 Boy Scouts and 9 adults. They did great!

Paul

Apr 16, 2025

Very hearty sandwiches. Could only eat half. Counter help was very accommodating, made recommendations for this picky eater. Nice environment. Photos on wall brought a sense of nostalgia. Nice, bright, friendly place. Thank you for being so welcoming!

Carlton Lemley

Mar 26, 2025

Fantastic Sandwiches in downtown Cloudcroft. We had the Turkey, bacon, avocado, Swiss and it really hit the spot. Soup was forgettable but the sandwiches will cover a multitude of sins. Staff was very friendly as well- highly recommend if you’re looking for a lunch spot in Cloudcroft